Feature

Nostalgia and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

A remake is often seen as an easy way to cash in on nostalgia. Aging Millennials and Gen Xers have weathered a lot of nasty stuff in our adulthoods, from back-to-back financial crises to decades-long wars. There’s obviously something so pure and warm about retreating into our memories, to a time when maybe the world still had its problems, but we didn’t know about them, because we were kids, and our parents shielded us from them. Because human beings are fundamentally storytellers, the easiest way we have to escape to memory land is via the media we enjoyed as children. With movies and books, that’s an easy thing to do. Pretty much every movie is available in some form somewhere, and I can watch them all on my smart TV, right now if I wanted to. Used bookstores are still relatively accessible, and if you’re okay with digital, there’s Kindle, meaning you can re-buy your entire childhood library and keep it in your back pocket. Every song can be streamed. Old media is more accessible than ever before.

Video games are a different story, though. Technology in this space evolved differently. Too many companies wanted too big a piece of the pie, so every new hardware generation is full of devices that don’t share compatibility, either with each other or even their own prior iterations. The coding that makes each game run is written to exact specifications, which means backwards compatibility is often a headache that companies aren’t interested in taking on. It’s not easy, and it’s not cheap. So, unless you have an old tube TV, a working N64, and a functioning copy of a game from the mid-90s, you’re going to have some difficulty getting a true-to-memory experience with any game from that era.

This is where remakes come in. They’re a way for video game publishers to sell to an already-engaged audience with the promise of something they love, but better. But not all remakes hit the mark, or at least they don’t hit the mark that certain fans have set for them. The Final Fantasy VII Remake games are, in my opinion, some of the most brilliant pieces of storytelling in modern video games, but there is a vocal contingent of gamers who view them as blasphemy for how they stray from the original in significant ways, in both story and gameplay. Nintendo has largely avoided this problem by taking the somewhat conservative but ultimately fruitful path of closely hewing to the design philosophy of the original game. We saw this recently in Super Mario RPG, a remake of the 90s classic for Super NES. It added some new elements, but by and large it was just a much, much prettier version of the game we already knew and loved.

For The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, Nintendo did something very similar, though at a much larger scale. There are new elements here, for sure, including some pretty significant gameplay tweaks that feel incredible; but no one will accuse this of being unfaithful to the original.

The elusive 1-to-1 remake is rare in part because game developers don’t see their work the same way we as players do. When a developer makes a video game, they may be very proud of it, sure. Over time, that pride might remain, but what can also creep in is a sense that the final product just didn’t live up to all their expectations. Distance from the project can lead to a desire to change things. Dare I say, improve them. And for those developers who get a chance to fully remake a classic game from the ground up, this is the opportunity of a lifetime. This mentality often conflicts with fans’ desire for the new version of the game to remain exactly as it was. For fans, that game came to them as a near-perfect creation, and it crystallized in their minds as this untouchable thing. The idea of changing it is inconceivable. You wouldn’t paint over the Mona Lisa, would you? You wouldn’t sculpt clothes onto Michelangelo’s David.

I’m not here to make a value judgment about which position is objectively right or wrong. I can honestly see both sides’ points. There are games that I hold up as masterpieces that need no changes whatsoever to remain timeless. There are games (like the aforementioned Final Fantasy VII remake series) where I welcome the new insights and mechanics from the original creators. But Nintendo has clearly chosen one of these paths, and in this case, I do think it was the right choice.

Exactly how Nintendo was able to pull off such a faithful remake is interesting. Series producers Eiji Aonuma and Hidemaro Fujibayashi consciously took a step back from the development team – a team made up primarily of younger developers who didn’t work on the original – and gave them instructions to change what they felt was necessary but leave the rest the same. This must have required an enormous amount of restraint. Though, thinking about it, maybe it’s a bit different for these two than it would be if, say, Shigeru Miyamoto had been in charge of development. Aonuma was a designer on the original game, sure, but he wasn’t the man running the show. That wouldn’t happen until Majora’s Mask. And Fujibayashi may direct modern Zelda, but he wasn’t even with Nintendo when the original Ocarina was being made. I think it’s both these things, plus a dev team that likely played and loved the game as kids, that allowed for a remake like this to happen. The product that comes from this has all the original game’s DNA: being overseen by original creators, made fully in-house by the original company with full access to whatever resources they might need. But it’s not being driven by a desire to change what isn’t broken, to introduce ideas the original developers had late into the process and weren’t able to implement or the like. It’s the closest you can come to an “objective” recreation. In some situations, that might read as “soulless,” but here it most definitely is not. As a lover of the original game – as someone whose childhood involved many repeated replays – this is a game that gets it right.

In order for a remake to fully satisfy that nostalgic urge, it has to, more than anything, feel like the original. And I think sometimes, the original creators’ hands are not necessarily the ones best suited to recapturing that feel. The outside person, the fan, has the clearest opportunity to sculpt the game in its crystallized form that’s existed in all our memories for so long.

On the flip side of all this, it’s important to note that this might lead to a game that is perfect for fans of the original but alienating for new players. And since I’m a huge fan of the original game, I don’t think I’m fully qualified to say how new players are going to feel about Ocarina of Time on Switch 2. I suspect, though, that there’s enough polish, enough modern sensibility, enough familiar DNA here for Ocarina virgins to find a game worthy of all the hype. Ocarina of Time birthed the modern action-adventure genre, and almost every game in that genre owes much of its existence to it.

We’ll have a full review of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time soon. In the meantime, please share your thoughts as you play through the game in the comments below. If you’re new to the game, definitely let us know how you’re receiving it, because I’m extremely curious.

Be the first to comment.

Remember, be respectful of others. Comments that are not up to community standards will be deleted.